Life Principles - The art of thoughtful disagreement

business, establishing a business, startup-3639565.jpg

People who change their mind because they learned something are the winner, whereas those who stubbornly refuse to learn are the losers.

When two people believe opposite things, chances are that one of them is wrong. It pays to find out if that someone is you. That’s why it is important that you appreciate and develop the art of thoughtful disagreement.

In thoughtful disagreement, the goal is not to convince the other party that you are right – it is to find out which view is true and decide what to do about it. In thoughtful disagreement, both parties are motivated by the genuine fear of missing important perspectives. Exchanges in which you really see what the other person is seeing and they really see what you are seeing – with both your “higher-level you’s” trying to get the truth – are immensely helpful and a giant source of untapped potential.

To do this well, you need to approach the conversation in a way that conveys that you are just trying to understand. Use questions rather than make statements. Conduct the discussion in a calm and dispassionate manner and encourage the other person to do that as well. Remember, you are not arguing, you are openly exploring what is true. Be reasonable and expect others to be reasonable. If you are calm, collegial, and respectful you will do a lot better than if you are not. You’ll get better at this with practice.

To me, its pointless when people get angry with each other when they disagree because most disagreement s aren’t threats as much as opportunities for learning. People who change their mind because they learned something are the winner, whereas those who stubbornly refuse to learn are the losers.

You should be what I call open-minded and assertive at the same time – you should hold and explore conflicting possibilities in your mind while moving fluidly towards whatever is likely to be true based on what you learn. Some people can do this easily while others can’t. A good exercise to make sure that you are doing this well is to describe back to the person you are disagreeing with their perspective. If they agree that you’ve got it, then you are in good shape. I also recommend that both parties observe a “two-minute rule” in which neither interrupts the other, so they both have time to get all their thoughts out.

Some people worry that operating this way is time consuming. Working through disagreement does take time but its just about the best way you can spend it. What’s important is that you prioritize what you spend time on and who you spend it with.

There are lots of people who will disagree with you, and it would be unproductive to consider all their views. It doesn’t pay to be open-minded with everyone. Spend your time exploring ideas with the most believable people you have access to.

If you find you’re at an impasse, agree on a person you both respect and enlist them to help moderate the discussion. What’s counter-productive is spinning in your own head about what’s going in, which most people are prone to do – or wasting time disagreeing past the point of diminishing returns. When that happens, move on to a more productive way of getting to a mutual understanding, which isn’t necessarily the same thing as agreement. For example, you might agree to disagree.

Why doesn’t thoughtful disagreement like this this typically occur?

Because most people are instinctively reluctant to disagree. For example, if two people go to a restaurant and one says he likes the food, the other is more likely to say “I like it too” or not say anything at all, even if that’s not true. The reluctance to disagree is the “lower-level you’s” mistaken interpretation of disagreement as conflict. That’s why radical open-mindedness isn’t easy: You need to teach yourself the art of having exchanges in wats that don’t trigger such reactions in yourself or others.

Holding wrong opinions in one’s head and making bad decisions based on them instead of having thoughtful disagreement is one of the greatest tragedies of mankind. Being able to thoughtfully disagree would so easily lead to radically improved decision making in all areas – Public policy, medicine, philanthropy, personal relationship and more.

Culled from Ray Dalio’s Principles

Related Posts

sylvester, happy new year, sparkling wine

Cheers to 2025

Every New Year holds promise, as though it is any different from the turn of

I Parked My Car Five Minutes Away: So the Kids Wouldn’t See It.

There is a particular kind of silence that falls on a man when the phone stops ringing, the proposals go unanswered, and the diary that once groaned under the weight of appointments sits quietly — almost mockingly — open. If you have ever been there, you know it.

Wired for Me

Let me tell you something uncomfortable: the most generous person you know — the one who volunteers every weekend, donates quietly, never asks for anything in return — is probably getting something out of it. Not money. Maybe not even recognition. But something.

When the Burnt Toast Saves Your Life

Adaeze had been awake since 4 a.m.
Not because she was anxious — though she was — but because this trip felt different. After eighteen months of follow-ups, phone calls, and PowerPoint presentations polished to a mirror shine, the deal was finally ready to close. An investor meeting in Abuja. A partnership that would change the trajectory of her small but gutsy consulting firm. She had triple-checked her flight, her documents, her outfit. She had prayed. She was ready.

The Loudest Person in Every Room Is Often the Most Afraid

When he told his father, Dare’s first response was a sigh. Then: “I told you to practice more. I told you months ago. You don’t listen. You never listen.”

There was no “I’m sorry, son.” No pause to let the boy simply feel the loss of the thing he wanted. Just a swift, seamless pivot to what Temi had done wrong — and, by extension, how Temi’s failure was evidence of Temi’s failure to take his father’s wisdom seriously.

You Only Heard One Side. That’s the Problem

I want to tell you something that took me embarrassingly long to learn. Not because the idea is complicated — it is not. But because it cuts against something deeply wired in us, something we are rarely honest enough to admit.

Everything You Were Too Embarrassed to Google About Mid-Life Crisis

You are somewhere between forty and fifty-five. You looked in the mirror recently and had a thought you immediately dismissed. Maybe you googled something at 2am that you would never say out loud. Maybe you bought something expensive and impractical and told everyone it was an investment. Or maybe you just feel — quietly, persistently — like the life you built was supposed to feel better than this by now.

Chekhov’s Gun

Anton Chekhov was a Russian physician and playwright — a man trained in the discipline of diagnosis before he became one of the most precise storytellers in the history of world literature. That combination of sensibilities matters, because the principle he articulated in the late nineteenth century was not merely a rule of dramatic craft. It was an observation about the nature of significance itself. About what it means for something to be present. About the relationship between introduction and consequence.

Fear Is a Prison with Invisible Walls

There is a prison that has no concrete walls, no iron bars, no guards posted at the gate. Nobody built it for you. Nobody sentenced you to it. And yet, for many people, it is the place they spend the better part of their lives — circling its perimeter, brushing their fingers against its invisible boundaries, and quietly retreating each time they feel the edge of something that might require more of them than they believe they can give.

The Closed Fist

Picture a hand holding sand. The tighter the grip, the faster the grains escape between the fingers. Ease the grip — open the palm, allow the hand to become a vessel rather than a vice — and the sand stays. This is one of the oldest paradoxes of leadership, and one of the least learned: that control, pursued too aggressively, produces the very loss of control it was designed to prevent.

The Growth Trap

There is a version of ambition that builds. And there is a version of ambition that consumes. From a distance — and especially from inside it — they look almost identical. Both are energetic. Both are forward-moving. Both speak the language of vision and possibility. The difference only becomes visible later, usually at the point of fracture, when what was built begins to come apart under the weight of what was promised.

The Frontline Disconnect

There is a particular kind of organisational absurdity that most people who have ever worked in a company will recognise immediately. It is the policy that was clearly designed by someone who has never had to implement it. The restructuring that looked elegant on a slide deck and chaotic on the ground. The customer-facing process that was overhauled by a committee that has not spoken to a customer in years. The directive that arrives from above, fully formed and non-negotiable, that causes the people closest to the work to exchange a look — the kind of look that says, without words: they have no idea what we actually do here.

Burnout Is a Leadership Failure

We have built an entire mythology around exhaustion. In boardrooms and business culture — perhaps nowhere more so than in the high-pressure, always-on professional culture many of us inhabit — busyness has become a currency. To be tired is to be serious. To be overwhelmed is to be important. To be burning out, quietly, is somehow proof that you are fully committed.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

8 thoughts on “Life Principles – The Art of Thoughtful disagreement”

    1. Thoughtful disagreement, really an art and needs to be learnt. Thanks omo Akin, reading from you somehow is able to drain fatigue out of my body.. Nice one brother

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Discover more from Akin Akingbogun

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

error: Content is protected !!

Discover more from Akin Akingbogun

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Contact Us

Just write down some details about you and we will get back to you in a jiffy!